VPN comparison
CyberFence vs. Private Internet Access
US-operated all-in-one protection vs. one of the largest US-based VPN networks with heavy annual upsells.
Quick answer: CyberFence Complete at $10.99/mo bundles VPN, Breach Monitor, and Web Shield in one plan with a US support team and PDF breach reports for compliance. Private Internet Access (PIA) advertises intro pricing as low as $2.03/mo on 3-year plans, but the monthly plan is $11.95/mo and add-ons (antivirus, dedicated IP, identity monitoring) each cost extra. If you're comparing at renewal on a monthly cadence, CyberFence is cheaper and includes more.
Feature-by-feature comparison
Side-by-side. No cherry-picking. We show where they beat us too.
Pick CyberFence if…
- You want VPN, breach monitoring, and Web Shield in one $10.99/mo bill instead of buying Identity Guard and Antivirus as add-ons.
- You do NOT want a 3-year commitment to lock in the good price — CyberFence is the same $10.99/mo on any cadence.
- You need exportable PDF breach reports for compliance (SOC 2, HIPAA vendor reviews, CPA WISP).
- You want a small US support team you can email and get a fast reply from — not a big-company ticket queue.
- You run a small team and want self-serve Teams billing from $9/seat/mo instead of a sales call.
Pick Private Internet Access if…
- You want the biggest US-based server fleet you can get — PIA operates 35,000+ servers, more than most competitors combined.
- You will commit to a 3-year plan to lock in the ~$2/mo intro rate and accept the renewal price later.
- You need unlimited simultaneous devices on one account — a large household or small studio setup.
- You value the court-tested no-logs history — PIA has been served US subpoenas and produced nothing (2016, 2018).
- You want a longer 30-day refund window instead of a 7-day free trial.
Our honest verdict
For most US-based individuals and small businesses who want one predictable bill, CyberFence Complete at $10.99/mo is the stronger choice — you get VPN, Breach Monitor, Web Shield, and PDF compliance reports without the 3-year commitment or add-on stack. PIA is the right pick if you want a huge global server fleet, are willing to prepay 3 years to lock in intro pricing, or specifically value the court-tested no-logs history. Both are US-based and legitimate; the choice is bundle vs. build-your-own.
Frequently asked questions
Is Private Internet Access really $2/mo?
Only on the 3-year plan and only for the first term. The monthly plan is $11.95/mo and the 1-year plan is roughly $3.33/mo. When any long-term plan renews, the price steps up. CyberFence Complete is $10.99/mo at any cadence, no intro/renewal game.
Is PIA cheaper than CyberFence over 3 years?
On the VPN line item, PIA's 3-year prepay is meaningfully cheaper if you can commit that far out. CyberFence Complete's value is the bundle — $10.99/mo includes Breach Monitor ($5.99/mo value) and Web Shield. If you'd also buy PIA Identity Guard and PIA Antivirus, the total cost of a comparable stack is closer.
Is PIA a legitimate no-logs VPN?
Yes — one of the most credible in the industry. PIA has been served US subpoenas twice (2016, 2018) and produced no user data because none existed. That court-tested record is a legitimate reason to pick PIA over any VPN whose no-logs claim has only been audited.
Does CyberFence have as many servers as PIA?
No. PIA operates 35,000+ servers in 91 countries — one of the largest fleets on the market. CyberFence's network is US-focused and optimized for streaming, banking, and reliable business travel. If your priority is global server variety, PIA wins.
Which one is better for a small business or team?
CyberFence — its Teams plan is self-serve from $9/seat/mo with an admin dashboard and exportable compliance reports. PIA Teams is sold separately as a sales-led product, which means a call, a quote, and typically a higher per-seat cost.
Which one has better customer support?
PIA has 24/7 live chat and a large support team. CyberFence provides US-based email support with typical replies in under 4 hours during business hours and priority support for Teams customers. If synchronous chat matters most, PIA wins.
Try CyberFence risk-free for 7 days.
Complete plan · VPN + Breach Monitor + Web Shield · $10.99/mo · Cancel anytime.